Spiritual gaslighting can occur anywhere, even in a place as sacred as your church.
This form of manipulation involves a person or group causing you to question your faith or spiritual experiences.
What makes it so insidious is that the perpetrators often disguise their motives beneath the guise of faith or teachings, making it hard to identify.
By being aware of certain phrases, however, you can start to recognize when this is happening.
Here are 10 phrases that could signal spiritual gaslighting within your church.
1. “Your faith isn’t strong enough”
This phrase is a classic example of spiritual gaslighting. It operates under the assumption that any problem you’re facing is due to your lack of faith or spiritual strength.
This type of comment can make you question your faith and spiritual commitment, leading to feelings of guilt and inadequacy.
But remember, everyone’s faith journey is different and personal. There’s no one-size-fits-all measure of spiritual strength or faith.
It’s essential to understand that struggles and doubts are part of the faith journey, not indicators of weak faith. Your spiritual growth is not determined by the absence of problems but by how you navigate through them with God’s guidance.
In cases where this phrase is used, it’s important to recognize it as a form of manipulation, not a reflection of your spiritual worth or faith.
2. “God told me you should…”
This phrase is arguably one of the most manipulative when used in the wrong context.
Why?
Well, because it asserts that the speaker has a superior connection with God and is a conduit for His will concerning your life.
The intention behind this phrase may vary. Some may use it out of genuine concern, but others may use it to control or manipulate you, making it spiritual gaslighting.
It’s important to remember that God communicates with each of us individually. While He can use others to speak into our lives, it’s crucial for each of us to seek His guidance personally and directly.
When you hear this phrase, seek discernment from God, test it against Scripture, and consult trusted spiritual advisors.
Trust me, your personal relationship with God is paramount, and no one else’s ‘revelation’ should override that.
3. “You’re not praying enough”
This phrase, similar to the first point, places the blame squarely on your shoulders. The underlying message is that your struggles or problems are a direct result of your insufficient prayer life.
Let’s get one thing straight:
Prayer is a vital part of our spiritual walk. It connects us with God, helps us align with His will, and provides comfort and strength.
But using it as a tool to shame or control others is not its intended purpose.
When you hear this phrase, it’s crucial to remember that the quantity of prayers does not necessarily equate to their efficacy. The Bible speaks of the quality of our prayers – a sincere heart and faith in God (Matthew 6:7).
Your prayer life is personal and should not be used as a measuring stick for your spirituality by others.
If someone tells you that you’re not praying enough, take it as an opportunity to evaluate your prayer life personally, rather than feeling condemned or manipulated.
4. “You’re causing division”
Have you ever been accused of causing division just for expressing a different opinion or questioning something in your church?
The thing is that this phrase is often used to suppress dissent and maintain control.
Here’s the deal:
The Bible encourages unity among believers, but it also values truth and righteous judgment. Expressing a differing viewpoint or asking questions should not automatically label you as a troublemaker or someone causing division.
Spiritually healthy communities encourage open dialogue, questions, and respectful disagreements. They understand that these elements can lead to deeper understanding and spiritual growth.
Insight: In Acts 17:11, the Berean Jews were praised for examining the Scriptures daily to verify Paul’s teachings. This shows that questioning and verifying religious teachings is biblically supported.
5. “Don’t question, just have faith”
This phrase is a common tool used in spiritual gaslighting. It discourages critical thinking and promotes blind faith, which can lead to manipulation and control.
As followers of Christ, we are encouraged to seek understanding and wisdom. Blind faith is not the goal; rather, an informed faith that stands the test of time is.
When confronted with this phrase, remember these important truths:
- Questioning is not a sign of weak faith
- Seeking understanding can strengthen your faith
- God welcomes our questions and doubts
Your faith should not be used as a tool to suppress your curiosity or quiet your concerns. It should be a journey of constant learning, growing, and seeking God’s truth.
6. “You’re being led astray”
Here’s a phrase that can be particularly damaging.
It suggests that any questioning, doubts, or divergence from the established norm is a sign of being led astray.
We need to understand that spiritual growth often involves periods of questioning and seeking. It’s a part of the process where we evaluate our beliefs and understand them more deeply.
If someone accuses you of being led astray because you’re seeking answers or expressing doubts, it can be a form of spiritual gaslighting. This phrase is used to make you doubt your spiritual journey and conform to their perspective.
Remember, your journey with God is personal and unique. It’s okay to question, to seek answers, and even to doubt.
These are not signs of being led astray but are often indicators of growth.
7. “You’re letting the devil in”
When you voice concerns, doubts, or disagreements within your church, you might be met with the phrase, “You’re letting the devil in”.
This phrase is used to frighten you into compliance by suggesting that your doubts, concerns or disagreements are not just wrong, but actually evil.
It’s a way of delegitimizing your feelings or thoughts by attributing them to malicious forces.
But remember, having doubts, questions, and disagreements is a natural part of any spiritual journey. They don’t make you evil or suggest that you’re under the influence of sinister forces.
Recognizing this phrase as a form of spiritual gaslighting can help you maintain your spiritual autonomy and resist attempts to manipulate your faith journey.
8. “You’re spiritually immature”
A phrase that once made me question my worth and faith was, “You’re spiritually immature”.
I recall a time when I questioned certain doctrines that didn’t align with my understanding of love and compassion. Instead of engaging in a fruitful discussion, I was labeled as ‘spiritually immature’.
This phrase is often used to belittle your understanding and dismiss your concerns.
It can make you feel as if you’re not as enlightened or worthy as others in your spiritual community.
However, remember that having questions or a different understanding doesn’t make you immature.
It’s a part of your spiritual growth and journey. Recognizing this phrase as spiritual gaslighting can help you stand up for yourself and your faith.
9. “God will punish you for questioning”
The threat of divine punishment is often used to silence questions or doubts.
The phrase, “God will punish you for questioning”, is a potent tool in the arsenal of spiritual gaslighters.
This phrase seeks to instill fear and guilt, discouraging you from expressing your doubts or seeking answers. It’s a manipulative tactic that uses your faith against you, turning it into a tool of control.
But remember, faith is not about fear. It’s about love, understanding, and the pursuit of truth. Questioning and seeking understanding is a crucial part of your spiritual journey.
But once you recognize this phrase for what it is – an attempt at spiritual gaslighting – it can help you maintain your spiritual autonomy and ensure your faith remains a source of comfort and growth, not fear and manipulation.
10. “You’re not truly saved”
Imagine you’ve been faithfully attending church, participating in church activities, and following the teachings of your faith.
Then someone tells you, “You’re not truly saved.”
This phrase is an ultimate form of spiritual gaslighting as it directly attacks your salvation – the core of your Christian faith.
It’s important to remember that your salvation is not determined by human judgment but by God’s grace through faith in Jesus Christ.
If someone questions your salvation based on their perception or criteria, it’s a clear sign of spiritual gaslighting. They’re imposing their judgment over God’s grace and mercy.
Your relationship with God is deeply personal. No one has the authority to invalidate your experience or relationship with Him.
If you’ve put your trust in Jesus Christ, rest assured in the promise of salvation given in John 3:16 and Romans 10:9.
Stepping forward with discernment
Recognizing spiritual gaslighting in your church is a crucial step towards safeguarding your spiritual health.
It’s essential to hold on to the truth that your relationship with God is personal and unique. And no one should have the power to control or manipulate it.
- Stand firm in your faith and your personal relationship with God
- Keep seeking wisdom and discernment from the Holy Spirit
- Remember that questioning and seeking understanding is a part of spiritual growth
The Bible encourages us to “test everything; hold fast what is good” (1 Thessalonians 5:21).
Let’s apply this wisdom when we encounter phrases or situations that seem manipulative.
What would Jesus say?
Unsure whether to move on from a failed marriage? Struggling with desire and feeling guilty for it? Wanting to live a life Jesus would be proud of?
Let Jesus tell you how to be a good Christian according to the teachings of the Bible.
We brought Jesus back to life with the help of AI. Ask your toughest life questions, and Jesus will tell you exactly what to do.
