Imagine this: you’re at a family gathering, and everyone is enjoying a pleasant conversation.
Then, out of nowhere, a relative steers the discussion into controversial territory, turning what was a light-hearted exchange into a heated debate. You can feel the tension rising, and the last thing you want is to ruin the mood or get sucked into an argument that leads nowhere.
We’ve all been there—trapped in a conversation with someone who seems determined to stir the pot.
It’s tempting to either fight back or completely shut down, but neither leaves you feeling great afterward. The real challenge is handling these situations with elegance, keeping your cool without getting dragged into conflict.
Curious how to do it? In this article, we’ll reveal a few refined strategies to manage argumentative people, so you can navigate these tricky moments with grace and composure. Keep reading to discover how to keep the peace—and your sanity—intact.
1) Practice active listening
It’s a common misconception that dealing with an argumentative person requires a lot of talking.
In reality, one of the most effective and classy tactics is active listening.
Active listening goes beyond merely hearing the words spoken by the other person. It involves giving full attention, understanding the message, and responding thoughtfully.
By truly listening to an argumentative person, you’re not just pausing to speak next. You’re showing that you value their perspective, even if you don’t agree with it.
This approach can help diffuse tension and prevent escalation.
But active listening requires practice. It’s a skill that needs to be honed over time.
As renowned psychologist Carl Rogers once said, “When someone really hears you without passing judgment on you, without trying to take responsibility for you, without trying to mold you, it feels damn good.” When you make others feel heard, they are more likely to reciprocate the respect.
2) Respond, don’t react
Reacting in the heat of the moment is a natural impulse, especially when dealing with an argumentative person. Reactions are emotional and uncontrolled, which can escalate the situation instead of resolving it.
A more mindful approach is to respond thoughtfully. A response is calm, deliberate, and considers both your feelings and those of the other person.
In my experience, responding helps maintain composure and handle the situation with grace.
This method doesn’t mean backing down or letting the other person “win.” It focuses on ensuring the conversation remains respectful and open, paving the way for better understanding and resolution.
3) Use “I” statements
This is a strategy used in conflict resolution and it’s backed by psychology.
“I” statements are a simple yet effective way to express your feelings without blaming or criticizing the other person. They shift the focus from the other person’s behavior to your own feelings and experiences.
This approach involves structuring your responses in a way that highlights how the situation affects you. For example, instead of saying “You always interrupt me,” you could say, “I feel unheard when I’m interrupted.”
By framing your responses this way, you’re avoiding a direct attack on the other person which can often escalate an argument. You’re expressing your feelings in a non-threatening way which can help the other person to better understand your perspective.
4) Agree to disagree
Now this might seem counter-intuitive, but hear me out.
There are times when despite your best efforts, you and the argumentative person just won’t see eye-to-eye. And that’s okay. Not every disagreement needs to be resolved with one person changing their opinion.
In such situations, it can be very classy to simply agree to disagree. This means acknowledging that you both have valid points and that it’s okay to have different opinions.
Doing this can help prevent the situation from escalating further. It shows respect for the other person’s viewpoint and also demonstrates your maturity in handling disagreements.
5) Focus on the issue, not the person
Dealing with an argumentative person requires separating the individual from the issue at hand.
Getting personal during heated discussions leads to attacking someone’s character or bringing up past mistakes, which can quickly escalate the situation and divert attention from resolving the main issue.
Maintain focus on the topic being discussed. Address the argument, not the person. This approach helps keep emotions in check and prevents the situation from spiraling out of control.
The words of Sigmund Freud, “Being entirely honest with oneself is a good exercise,” resonate strongly here. In arguments, focusing on honesty about the issue rather than targeting the individual is a practice worth striving for.
6) Take a time-out
There was an incident where a family disagreement became quite heated. Emotions ran high, voices were raised, and resolution seemed out of reach.
In the midst of it, I suggested a time-out—a pause for everyone to step away, cool down, and collect their thoughts.
Taking a break during an argument can be incredibly beneficial. It allows you to regain composure, gather your thoughts, and approach the situation with a fresh perspective.
Mark Black wisely observed, “Sometimes the most productive thing you can do is relax.” This pause can help break down barriers, offering a chance to step back from judgment and re-engage with understanding.
7) Practice empathy
Empathy is a powerful tool when dealing with an argumentative person.
Empathy involves putting yourself in the other person’s shoes and trying to understand their feelings and perspective. It doesn’t mean you have to agree with them, but it does involve acknowledging their feelings.
When you show empathy, you’re showing the other person that you respect their feelings and opinions. This can help deescalate the situation and open up a more meaningful dialogue.
It’s also important to keep in mind that everyone has their own reasons for their beliefs and behaviors. Just as we want our feelings to be understood, we must strive to understand others as well.
8) Keep the big picture in mind
In the heat of an argument, it’s tempting to focus on winning rather than resolving the issue. The challenge lies in maintaining perspective.
This is where keeping the big picture in mind comes into play. Ask yourself: What’s the ultimate goal here? Is it to prove who’s right, or is it to reach a mutual understanding?
By focusing on the bigger picture, you’re able to steer the conversation away from petty disagreements and towards a more constructive resolution.
Viktor Frankl encapsulated this beautifully: “Between stimulus and response there is a space. In that space is our power to choose our response. In our response lies our growth and our freedom.”
Staying aware of the bigger picture empowers you to respond in ways that foster understanding and progress, rather than intensifying the conflict.
Final thoughts: It’s all about balance
Navigating an argument can be both complex and challenging. It’s not only about managing the disagreement but also about maintaining respect and understanding.
The key is to balance standing your ground with preventing escalation. It’s about articulating your point of view while respecting the other person’s perspective.
Every interaction is an opportunity for growth. Even the most difficult arguments can offer insights into ourselves and others.
Keep these strategies in mind as you handle such situations. They can help you manage the argument more effectively and foster more harmonious relationships.
Carl Jung aptly noted, “Everything that irritates us about others can lead us to an understanding of ourselves.” Let every encounter, even the argumentative ones, be a step towards deeper understanding and personal growth.
Related Stories from Bible Scripture
What would Jesus say?
Unsure whether to move on from a failed marriage? Struggling with desire and feeling guilty for it? Wanting to live a life Jesus would be proud of?
Let Jesus tell you how to be a good Christian according to the teachings of the Bible.
We brought Jesus back to life with the help of AI. Ask your toughest life questions, and Jesus will tell you exactly what to do.