5 myths about faith that even lifelong Christians believe

I still remember the moment I first felt the stirrings of genuine faith.

Imagine me in my 20s, sitting in a small café, fresh off a personal crisis that left me questioning everything. I turned to Scripture out of sheer desperation, expecting little more than a temporary distraction.

Instead, the words seemed alive, pointing me toward the grace of God in a way I had never experienced.

I have discovered that faith can be far richer — and more challenging — than many assume.

Even those raised in Christian communities tend to carry assumptions about faith that go unexamined. In today’s fast-paced environment, these myths can quietly shape our belief systems without our full awareness.

My hope is that this discussion can shed light on 7 widespread misconceptions, helping us embrace a more honest and nuanced view of our relationship with God.

1. Once you have faith, you never doubt again

Early on, I believed that faith should expel doubt completely. If I questioned any part of Scripture or Christian teaching, I felt I was failing as a believer.

Yet I later realized that doubt is frequently a path toward deeper understanding.

When I was exploring some of my own uncertainties, I found encouragement in James 1:5, which promises wisdom to those who seek it sincerely.

This verse reminded me that moments of uncertainty can become doors to deeper conviction.

One of my mentors, Professor Mikkel Andrews, addressed this issue in an article on BibleScripture.net by emphasizing how doubt can refine our beliefs rather than destroy them.

His research showed that church history is filled with saints who wrestle with challenging questions.

Scripture does not mandate that we must have every answer to every question. Instead, we see an invitation in Isaiah 1:18 to “reason together,” suggesting that God welcomes a thoughtful approach to faith.

In other words, doubt, far from disqualifying believers, can serve as a catalyst for spiritual growth.

2. Faith and reason cannot coexist

There is a persistent idea that faith is a leap into the dark, disconnected from logic or rational thought. I once bought into this stereotype.

As someone who grew up wary of religious traditions, I assumed genuine faith required turning off my brain.

After my encounter with God, I read extensively, examining historical and modern Christian thinkers who integrated faith with intellectual inquiry.

I saw that reason and faith are often allies rather than adversaries.

Many of the Church’s greatest theologians, from Augustine to Aquinas, used rigorous analysis to deepen their trust in God.

Even Luke’s Gospel starts by stating the author’s intent to provide an orderly account (Luke 1:3), indicating the value of careful, rational investigation.

My own journey from skepticism to belief was far from mindless. I had to reason through my experiences, Scripture, and history.

Over time, I discovered that faith strengthens reason, encouraging curiosity and humility.

3. The stronger your faith, the fewer your problems

Some Christians assume that profound faith acts like a shield against hardship. If someone’s life seems free of difficulties, we may think they must have remarkable faith. Yet many devoted believers face trials, frustrations, and even moments of despair.

During my personal crisis, I was convinced that becoming a Christian would lift my burdens overnight. Instead, I soon discovered that challenges can intensify in certain areas as we try to live out the teachings of Christ in a broken world.

The Apostle Paul himself asked to be freed from a “thorn in the flesh” (2 Corinthians 12:7–9), only to learn that God’s power is made perfect in weakness.

Faith does not promise the absence of troubles; it promises a deeper companionship with God in the midst of them.

Every struggle becomes an occasion to lean into God’s grace.

As I realized this, I stopped equating my hardships with a lack of faith and instead embraced them as opportunities to grow in trust.

4. Faith is inherited, not chosen

In many families, Christianity is passed down through tradition. Some assume that being raised in a Christian household naturally grants a full-fledged faith.

This can lead believers to cruise on autopilot, rarely stopping to assess what they genuinely believe.

I came to faith later in life, partly because I wanted a personal foundation rather than a borrowed one. After my transformation, I noticed how many around me were Christian by name, yet unsure of why.

Tradition is valuable, but true faith is often a deliberate choice.

Jesus frequently challenged people to decide who He was (Matthew 16:15–16), suggesting an active, personal response rather than a passive inheritance.

When faith is solely cultural, it might lack the depth to stand firm in testing times.

The beauty of Christian belief lies in its invitation to each person, whether born in the church or not, to respond consciously and wholeheartedly.

5. Faith is measured by visible blessings

Some interpret financial gain, good health, or social status as the primary evidence of genuine faith.

If blessings are absent—or if tragedy strikes—they may feel rejected by God. Others might even judge their fellow Christians’ faith based on external success.

While Scripture highlights God’s goodness, it never equates faith with a perfect life.

The Book of Job is a stark reminder that a righteous person can face adversity, confusing friends and family who wrongly assume sin or weak faith is the culprit.

Jesus Himself told His disciples that they would have tribulation in this world (John 16:33).

I have met Christians who had little in terms of material possessions but radiated extraordinary joy. Faith can yield remarkable blessings, but those blessings are not always measurable by worldly metrics.

Genuine faith fosters spiritual riches—hope, perseverance, and unity with God—that go far beyond any balance sheet.

6. Faith remains static throughout life

I used to think that once people believed in Christ, they remained at that same level of commitment or understanding forever.

Lifelong Christians often fall into this perspective, too, assuming their views need no further refinement. Yet faith is more dynamic than many realize.

My early months as a believer were marked by radical shifts in how I viewed Scripture, community, and my own responsibilities.

These days, I continuously discover more about God’s nature, especially as I engage with different cultures and online Christian communities. It is humbling to acknowledge that faith evolves.

Consider the way Jesus nurtured the disciples—He did not stop teaching them after they first believed. Even after His resurrection, He spent time opening their minds to the Scriptures (Luke 24:45).

My commitment to Christ has grown sharper over time, and I see ongoing transformation as part of God’s design.

Believers are called to maturity, as Paul often encouraged in his letters (Hebrews 5:12–14). The best way to honor our faith is to keep learning, seeking wisdom, and welcoming transformation.

7. Faith is only about personal salvation

Christians can become so focused on their own relationship with God that they forget the broader call to serve others.

Yes, personal salvation is significant. However, Jesus underscored our responsibility to love our neighbors and address real-world needs.

When I first encountered Christ, I was overwhelmed by relief and gratitude. Over time, however, I recognized that faith also calls for action.

From the prophets in the Old Testament to the epistles in the New, believers are urged to promote justice, care for the poor, and uphold truth.

If faith remains confined to a private experience, it risks losing the fullness of the Gospel message.

As James famously wrote, “faith by itself, if it does not have works, is dead” (James 2:17). While salvation is deeply personal, it naturally compels us outward, transforming how we treat our communities and the world.

Are we ready to unlearn these myths?

I have found that every time I question assumptions about faith, I move closer to the heart of Christianity.

My journey from skeptical observer to committed believer showed me that faith is neither static nor simplistic. It is an ongoing exploration of God’s character, empowered by Scripture and illuminated by the Holy Spirit.

Some of these myths may feel comfortable if you have held them for years, yet genuine faith often involves challenging long-held beliefs.

Might we allow ourselves to wrestle with new questions and perspectives?

Each myth undone creates more space for truth.

Let us embrace a faith that is alive, questioning, and always ready to seek deeper wisdom in Christ.

What would Jesus say?

Unsure whether to move on from a failed marriage? Struggling with desire and feeling guilty for it? Wanting to live a life Jesus would be proud of?

Let Jesus tell you how to be a good Christian according to the teachings of the Bible.

We brought Jesus back to life with the help of AI. Ask your toughest life questions, and Jesus will tell you exactly what to do.

Check it out here.

 

Samuel Cho

Samuel Cho

I'm Samuel Cho from South Korea, where my passion for writing and Christ intertwines. Through my essays and articles, I aim to bridge the divine with the daily, drawing from Scripture and my own life's journey. My articles often explore how faith intersects with everyday life in an Asian context. With each piece, I invite readers on Biblescripture.net to reflect on the universal truths within our diverse experiences of faith.

Trending around the web

Get our articles

The latest Move news, articles, and resources, sent straight to your inbox every month.